Submission Preflight

Find the route. Inspect the file.

Guide 06 / Journal manuscript

Move the trial report forward, not just the checklist date.

If a randomized-trial manuscript was prepared against CONSORT 2010, changing the label to CONSORT 2025 is not a review. Map the changed reporting areas to the draft, resolve the gaps with the study team, and then check the target journal's current instructions.

Source reviewed: the CONSORT group's published statements and expanded CONSORT 2025 checklist, plus the primary CONSORT 2025 statement and CONSORT 2010 statement in PLOS Medicine.

CONSORT 2025 was published on April 14, 2025. The statement supersedes CONSORT 2010 and provides a 30-item checklist for randomized-trial reports. A journal's adoption and submission requirements still come from that journal's current instructions.

Confirm that this is the right update

Use this migration review for a report of a completed randomized trial that was drafted with CONSORT 2010 in view. CONSORT 2025 addresses reporting, not whether the trial was well designed or correctly conducted. It also does not replace an applicable CONSORT extension or the target journal's format and submission rules.

The CONSORT group provides suggested instructions for journals, but the statement's publication date is not a universal enforcement date. Record the journal instructions you reviewed and the date you reviewed them.

Build a migration worksheet before editing

Create one row for each changed reporting area. Use four columns: the CONSORT 2025 area, where the current draft addresses it, the person who can confirm the underlying fact, and the next action. Mark an item unresolved when the manuscript location or study fact is unclear. Do not fill a reporting gap by guessing.

This worksheet separates source review from wordsmithing. It also gives a statistician, trial manager, or corresponding author a precise question instead of a general request to make the manuscript CONSORT-compliant.

Review the changed areas in three passes

  1. Access and disclosure. Locate the trial protocol and statistical analysis plan access statements. Review what the manuscript says about access to de-identified participant data, statistical code, and other materials, including an explanation when sharing is not planned. Confirm author conflicts of interest and describe patient or public involvement according to what actually occurred.
  2. Changes, analysis populations, and outcomes. Compare the draft with the protocol, statistical analysis plan, and registry for important changes after the trial began, including outcomes or analyses that were not prespecified. Define who was included in each analysis and in which group, explain how missing data were handled, and reconcile the number analyzed and the available-data count for each outcome, group, and time point.
  3. Delivery and harms. Distinguish the planned intervention and comparator from what participants actually received. Review relevant concomitant care and how harms or unintended effects were assessed, not only where the results appear.

These are review clusters, not a substitute checklist. Use the current expanded CONSORT 2025 checklist for the complete item wording and detail.

Reconcile the manuscript as one record

Read the methods, results, flow diagram, outcome tables, registry entry, protocol, and statistical analysis plan together. A correction in one place can expose a mismatch elsewhere. Keep the worksheet open until every changed area points to a manuscript location, an honest not-applicable explanation, or a named unresolved action.

Preserve the study record. CONSORT 2025 asks for transparent reporting of what happened. It does not authorize changing a trial fact, an analysis decision, or a registration history to make the manuscript look complete.

Finish with the journal handoff

Open the target journal's current author instructions after the content review. Confirm which checklist file, flow diagram, manuscript section, or supplementary material the journal asks authors to provide. If the journal still names an older CONSORT version, ask the journal how it wants the submission handled rather than assuming that the statement alone controls the portal.

For an early signal review, select the CONSORT 2025 profile in the Reporting Guideline Signal Check. The check can flag areas where common reporting language was not detected. It cannot determine checklist completeness, reporting compliance, study quality, or acceptance. If you still need to choose a study-design profile, use the reporting-guideline selection guide.

What this guide does not decide

This guide does not assess trial design, conduct, analysis, ethics, scientific validity, or journal fit. It does not establish that a manuscript complies with CONSORT 2025 or a journal's instructions. The current official checklist, applicable extensions, and receiving journal remain authoritative.

Start a CONSORT 2025 signal check

Browse all Submission Preflight guides.